Comparaison de deux liaisons avec des FAIs différents

[reich tsoumou]

Bonjour ! ! !

Je vous soumets ci-dessous 2 tests ping que j'ai effectué ce jour à partir de PC connectés sur FAI différents (le FAI fournit la liaison par BLR et le FAI 2 par VSAT). pour un abonnement, le coût est le même pour ces deux FAI.

J'aimerai avoir une idée de ces deux liaions: laquelle est meilleur ?

Laison FAI 1 (128Kbits/s) par antenne VSAT--------------------------------------------------------------------

C:\WINDOWS\system32>ping www.hotmail.com -t
Pinging www.hotmail.aate.nsatc.net [166.63.208.155] with 32 bytes of data:
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=675ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=735ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=700ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=759ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=723ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=694ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=755ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=719ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=686ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=747ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=705ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=763ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=728ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=691ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=753ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=719ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=682ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=766ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=734ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=697ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=757ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=725ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=728ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=788ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=780ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=659ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=754ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=715ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=718ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=717ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=678ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=741ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=707ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=677ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=683ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=686ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=746ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=752ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=685ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=749ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=713ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=677ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=736ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=704ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=690ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=698ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=675ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=735ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=704ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=675ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=736ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=700ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=755ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=716ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=777ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=827ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=759ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=733ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=701ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=747ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=692ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=762ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=732ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=690ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=664ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=712ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=674ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=742ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=707ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=773ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=761ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=752ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=747ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=701ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=675ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=695ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=737ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=741ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=749ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=703ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=729ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=713ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=676ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=742ms TTL=49
Reply from 166.63.208.155: bytes=32 time=708ms TTL=49
____________________________________________________________

Laison FAI 2 (128Kbits/s) par antenne BLR----------------------------------------------------------------------
C:\WINDOWS\system32>ping www.hotmail.com -t
Pinging www.hotmail.aate.nsatc.net [165.193.120.166] with 32 bytes of data:
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=929ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=690ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=741ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=703ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1345ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=704ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=778ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1148ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=693ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=826ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1266ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=687ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=703ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=697ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=695ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=790ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=828ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=692ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=691ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=714ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=789ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=696ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=745ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=689ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=684ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=679ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=682ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=755ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=686ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=679ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=683ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=849ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=711ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1099ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=773ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=684ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=755ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=685ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=694ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=901ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=700ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=679ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=705ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=685ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=705ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=692ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=740ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=763ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=691ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=715ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=715ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=682ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=733ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=702ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=688ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=782ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1338ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=695ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=857ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=773ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=682ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=702ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1033ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=822ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=744ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=767ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=724ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=697ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=681ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=688ms TTL=43
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=680ms TTL=42
Reply from 165.193.120.166: bytes=32 time=1098ms TTL=42
__________________________________________________

merci d'avance.

[bad_trips]

Bonjour à toi,


Il est vrai qu'avec la premiere connection les ping sont a des vitesses plus reguliere mais le truc c'est qu'il me semblait qu'un ping était le temps de reponse du site que tu pinguer donc rien a voir avec ta connection.

La solution pour savoir qu'elle connection et la plus rapide à mon avi c'est que tu te conecte en ftp sur les serveurs oceane c'est des serveur francais 100Mbits ou tu peut te connecter en anonyme dessus et faire des testes de dl ms tu pourras pas up dessus (ils sont pas fou non plus lol) en revanche je ne me rapelle plus de leur adresse ftp alors si une bonne âme connait il pourras te la donner.

En esperan pouvoir t'aider un peu plus la prochaine foi!